How that ache may signal depression

11 Sep

by Carolyn Thomas

There is a disturbing link between women’s heart disease and depression.  Those suffering depression are more at risk for developing heart disease, and those diagnosed with heart disease are more at risk for suffering depression. The majority of depressed people never get help, however, partly because they don’t know that, along with emotional changes, their physical symptoms might also be caused by depression. Doctors may miss these symptoms, too: 

  • Headaches: if you’re already prone to migraines, may become worse now
  • Back pain, muscle aches and joint pain: any kind of chronic pain may worsen
  • Chest pain: can be a serious sign of heart problems, but also common with depression
  • Digestive problems: queasiness, nausea, diarrhea, constipation
  • Exhaustion and fatigue: worn out no matter how much you sleep
  • Sleeping problems: sleep disruption, insomnia, or you may sleep more than usual
  • Change in appetite or weight: may lose your appetite, or crave high-carb foods
  • Dizziness or light-headedness

North Carolina psychotherapist Kristen McClure has this to say about physical symptoms of depression in women:

“This is one of the signs of depression in women that is not well studied or understood. Our body and our mind are really not separate. When we are depressed or anxious, our body may get physically ill, and may ache or hurt in ways that we can’t quite explain.

“It is not surprising that efforts to work on this division between mind and body such as meditation, physical exercise and yoga are now components of effective treatment for depression.”

She adds that, just as depression can manifest in physical symptoms, physical exercise has been shown to be surprisingly helpful for those diagnosed with depression.

“One of the most compelling studies done by Blumenthal* of Duke University Medical Center randomly assigned women to take medicine or exercise as treatment for mild to moderate depression, and found almost equal positive results.

“This means that women on antidepressants and women who exercised experienced equal relief from their symptoms.”

Here are some other suggestions for getting through depression:

  • Pace yourself. Don’t expect to do everything you normally can. Set a realistic schedule.
  • Don’t believe all of your negative thinking, such as blaming yourself, feeling hopeless or expecting to fail. This thinking is part of depression. These thoughts will go away as your depression lifts.
  • If you can, get involved in activities that make you feel good or make you feel like you’ve achieved something.
  • Social supports such as family, friends and support groups can be very beneficial.
  • Put off doing things that you find too difficult at the moment. Avoid making big
    life decisions during a depression. If you must make a big decision, ask someone you trust to help you.
  • Avoid drugs and alcohol. Both make depression worse. Both can cause dangerous side effects or get in the way of letting your medications work.
  • Try not to get discouraged. It’ll take time for your depression to lift fully. But treatment works for almost everyone.
  • Exercise! It not only gives you a distraction but also seems to cause a chemical reaction in the body that may make your mood better. Do it as much as you can. Three times a week for 30 minutes to one hour each time is a good goal, but even less can be helpful.
Source: College of Family Physicians of Canada

According to the Canadian Mental Health Association, depressive illness can change the way a person thinks and behaves, and how the body functions. Get help if the following symptoms are severe, last for several weeks, and begin to interfere with your work, family and/or social life:

  • feeling worthless, helpless or hopeless
  • sleeping more or less than usual
  • eating more or less than usual
  • having difficulty concentrating or making decisions
  • loss of interest in taking part in normal activities
  • decreased sex drive
  • avoiding other people
  • overwhelming feelings of sadness or grief
  • feeling unreasonably guilty
  • loss of energy, feeling very tired
  • thoughts of death or suicide

And here are even more disturbing facts about depression. We know that women in general are twice as likely to develop depression compared to their male counterparts.

When the former Globe and Mail reporter Jan Wong wrote about her own journey with debilitating depression in the memoir Out of the Blue, she described the life lessons that depression had taught her:

“The big life lessons are that you can have clinical depression and you can get over it. It’s completely treatable. It has an end. Second life lesson: you’ll probably be stronger when you come out of it than you were before. The third life lesson is you’ll probably be happier because you leave it behind and you will find a new life. The fourth lesson: that family matters. Everything else is extra.”

Women’s higher overall risk for depression, according to Dr. Nasreen Khatri of Toronto’s Baycrest Hospital, is likely due to a combination of factors, including:

  • biological ones like the effects on the brain of hormonal changes during pregnancy
  • social factors like the multiple roles women tend to play in modern society
  • psychological ones like different coping styles

Dr. Khatri adds that many middle-aged women today are also working full-time while caring for both their own children and elderly parents, thus increasing stress levels which in turn can lead to depression.

And depression itself appears to make women two times as susceptible to later developing Alzheimer’s disease, for reasons that are not yet entirely clear. What may not be well known is that seven out of 10 new cases are women, ironically, explains Dr. Khatri, the very people who more often than not take on the major responsibility for caring for dementia sufferers.

.

* Blumenthal et al, “Exercise and Pharmacotherapy in the Treatment of Major Depressive Disorder”. Psychosomatic Medicine, 2007; 69: 587-596

See also:

 

4 Responses to “How that ache may signal depression”

  1. Kimberly October 12, 2012 at 2:40 pm #

    The second sentence of this post really caught my attention: “Those suffering depression are more at risk for developing heart disease, and those diagnosed with heart disease are more at risk for suffering depression.”

    I have congenital heart disease, so I guess my situation is slightly different, but the reason I was interested by this one line is I was just discussing the idea with my therapist the other day. I do have a history of depression that began soon after a cardiac “event” — an atrial arrhythmia that caused my implanted defibrillator to shock me for the first time when I was twenty years old.

    I always ask myself whether or not I would struggle with depression if I did not have a heart condition.

    Do I have depression because I have heart disease, or would I have depression either way? Also, during my worse years of depression, my heart often entered into arrhythmia. Is there a connection? Once I met my husband and became happier, I stopped having as many incidents. So was the depression causing the cardiac issues?

    My therapist says it falls into the chicken-or-the-egg category and that like the age-old question, no one can really know the answer.

    Like

    • Carolyn Thomas October 12, 2012 at 6:57 pm #

      Hello Kimberly and thanks for sharing your story here. I suspect your therapist is right. Dr. Peter Liu of the University of Toronto once wrote: “The stress response can cause not just psychological trauma, but also physiological changes – such as increased heart rate and blood pressure – that further harm an injured heart.” Few things are more stressful in life than having a heart condition! No wonder we feel depressed (many experts now identify this as post traumatic stress disorder) and no wonder feeling depressed affects our hearts. A vicious circle!

      Like

  2. Jersey Girl November 5, 2011 at 6:40 am #

    I only wish I had read this article last year after surviving a heart attack/CABG x 3 (triple bypass open heart surgery). I was suffering from both depression and horrific physical symptoms, didn’t link the two at the time. THANK YOU on behalf of all women reading your excellent website.

    Like

  3. Skippie July 6, 2011 at 3:07 am #

    Thx so much for this. The MIND-BODY connection is so important yet often overlooked by our doctors.

    Like

Your opinion matters. What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: