by Carolyn Thomas ♥ @HeartSisters
After surviving a heart attack, I couldn’t wait to start my 3-month cardiac rehabilitation program so I would just start feeling “normal” again. But when I showed up for my first assessment, I was disappointed by the cardiac nurse’s recommendation that, because of ongoing issues, I should wait two months until I felt much stronger before starting. A Canadian study from the University of Alberta now suggests, however, that earlier might just be better for many.
For best results in most clinically stable patients after a heart attack, these new findings suggest that early exercise as well as prolonged exercise may well be the key to the best post-heart attack outcomes.
We know that previous studies overwhelmingly show that heart patients who exercise regularly are over 30% less likely to experience further heart attack, stroke or death. The U of A team found that stable patients who have suffered heart attacks get more benefits for heart performance when starting an exercise program one week after the heart attack than if they had waited a month or longer to begin cardiac rehabilitation. Co-author Dr. Mark Haykowsky of the U of A’s Faculty of Rehabilitation Medicine explained:
“While it’s been shown that exercise has a favourable effect on heart function, it’s also important to dispel the idea that what the heart needs is rest.”
One week after my own heart attack, I remember a stupefyingly slow one-block walk to the corner, leaning on the arm of my son Ben, and feeling distressingly frail and weak. My hospital discharge instructions had been to walk one block a day for the first week, two blocks the second week, and so on.
But the U of A study suggests that, in fact, the heart will actually become better with exercise sooner and with continued exercise over a longer period of time. Dr. Haykowsky’s study, published in the medical journal Trials, was a meta-analysis of 12 published studies on 647 post-heart attack patients (mean age: 55 years):
“In the past, patients in Canada and the U.S. have been told to wait for one month or longer before beginning their exercise treatment, and this treatment typically only goes on for about three months.”
But patients who begin an exercise program one week after their heart attack were found to have the best heart performance.
For those who waited to begin their exercise rehabilitation program, the results seem dramatic:
“For every week that a patient delayed his or her exercise treatment, he/she would have to train for the equivalent of one month longer to get similar benefits.”
Researchers found, in fact, that women may actually benefit more from exercise training:
“The heart uses both glucose and fatty acids for energy. After the training, men’s fatty acid metabolism dropped in response to energy demand, but the women’s increased. By that gauge, the women had a better response to exercise training than the men.”
Another early research study out of Duke University found that exercise especially helps those people who were labeled at-risk for heart disease. In blood samples taken after exercise, their study participants had an almost doubling of the brachial artery reactivity. This means that while exercise is beneficial for everyone, those with more cardiac risk factors may get extra benefit from exercise.
The U of A study authors report there was no evidence in the study to suggest that beginning an exercise program earlier that the typical waiting period had any detrimental effects.
“In the 1970’s, health care professionals were telling patients not to move for three months after a heart attack. Our findings suggest that stable patients need not wait a month to start exercising in a cardiac rehabilitation setting.”
Those early “stay in bed” directions of the past weren’t limited to the Coronary Care Unit. When I was a teenager, I spent one full month in my hospital bed – completely bedridden! – following a ruptured appendix and subsequent peritonitis. Nurses allowed me to get up and sit on a chair, shaky and very weak, for a few minutes at a time only when they changed the sheets. Well, no wonder I felt so weak. . .
Current medical wisdom, however, now gets open heart, knee replacement and mastectomy patients alike up out of that hospital bed and strolling the corridors as soon as reasonably possible post-op.
For heart patients, physical exercise also helps boost the nitric oxide levels in the endothelium, the lining of artery walls. One of the initial effects of coronary artery disease is damage to that lining, which exposes the vessels to harmful circulating cells. But nitric oxide released by the endothelium works to prevent red blood cells from sticking together, or aggregating, and attaching to the vessel wall. It can also work to control vascular tone, allowing the arteries to relax and stay clear.
Given that, in Canada, only one-third of patients are referred to rehabilitation after a heart attack and then only 20% of those actually attend, the U of A’s Dr. Haykowsky says the key to the best outcome is for patients to not only get referred to cardiac rehabilitation exercise programs, but to be referred early, participate and stick with it. He added:
“Exercise is a wonder drug that hasn’t been bottled.”
Even for heart patients living with chronic angina (described by Mayo Clinic as restricted blood flow to your heart that can cause recurrent episodes of chest pain called angina pectoris), it is important to work with your doctor to develop an exercise plan. Exercise can actually increase the level of pain-free activity, relieve stress, improve the heart’s blood supply, and help manage weight.
And yes, of course, sometimes, it’s not easy for us.
The other day, for example, my pedometer showed that I’d walked only 795 steps (out of my planned 5,000 step daily outing). But this total was approximately 794 more steps than I actually wanted to walk outdoors that day. Those 795 steps were at least SOMETHING on a day of crushing fatigue and distressing symptoms, a day when I really thought I would accomplish NOTHING.
Dr. Jan Gurley, who describes herself as “the only Harvard Medical School graduate to have been awarded a Shoney’s Ten-Step Pin for documented excellence in waitressing”, likes to advise:
“Think of exercise as your way of dosing yourself with health – and never skip a dose.”
Many doctors tell heart patients with angina pain to gradually build up their fitness level – for example, start with a 5-minute walk and increase over weeks or months up to 30-60 minutes. The idea is to gradually increase stamina by working at a steady pace.
This idea, however, may indeed be a tough sell to many heart patients, particularly if ongoing cardiac symptoms (frightening chest pain, fatigue, shortness of breath) make even the thought of doing any physical exercise enough to steer them back to the couch.
Let’s face it, when you’re in pain, you’re often reluctant to do anything that might increase that pain.
Consider those diagnosed with osteoarthritis of the knee – a debilitatingly painful condition. Having knee pain is self-limiting: if it hurts to walk, you want to walk less. But in a 2004 Journal of Rheumatology review of several randomized controlled trials of patients with knee osteoarthritis, however, increased levels of physical activity were found to actually result in modest but significant improvements in disability-related outcomes, specifically pain, health-related quality of life, and strengthened muscles around the knee, thus offering stability during ambulation and transfer from one location to another.
UPDATE, April 2022: Speaking of osteoarthritis, I have recently been diagnosed, too – with painful symptoms mostly in my left knee and both hands. Everything I’ve learned so far at physio and from my orthopedic surgeon confirms that journal review: “motion is lotion”. In fact, thanks to regular physiotherapy, stretching exercises, a good knee brace for walking, my pain symptoms are actually significantly improved since six months ago. See also: When Heart Disease Isn’t Your Biggest Problem
Physical activity is also a useful component of effective weight loss, partly because more calories are burned with increased physical activity, and because the more you exercise, the more positively you’ll approach exercise!
And it all just makes you feel better, inside and out.
NOTE FROM CAROLYN: I wrote more about the importance of moving your body if you’re a heart patient (or any other kind of patient!) in my book, “A Woman’s Guide to Living with Heart Disease“ (Johns Hopkins University Press). You can ask for this book at your local library or favourite bookshop, or order it online (paperback, hardcover or e-book) at Amazon – or order it directly from Johns Hopkins University Press (use their code HTWN to save 30% off the list price when you order).
Returning to Exercise (and Training) After Heart Surgery (THE best and most comprehensive overview on this topic I’ve seen yet, written by cardiologist and triathlete Dr. Larry Creswell; especially useful for heart patients who have been regular exercisers before their cardiac event and are wondering how to safely resume their routine)
What Prevents Heart Disease “Better Than Any Drug”?
Learning To Live With Heart Disease: The Fourth Stage of Heart Attack Recovery
Women-Only Cardiac Rehab Curbs Depression After Heart Attack
Why Aren’t Women Heart Attack Survivors Showing Up For Cardiac Rehab
Women’s Heart Health Advice: Walk Often, Walk Far
Physical exercise vs. the ‘plumber’s pipe’ theory of heart disease treatment
Can exercise trigger a heart attack?
4 thoughts on “Why your heart needs work – not rest! – after a heart attack”
I can’t tell you how many times I have said to my Tuesday running partner that I feel lousy and not to expect much, etc etc. And yes it is a very slow start, but I feel better as we make our way around the trail and by the end I feel good.
Same thing with cycling and swimming, the slow start, slower pace and longer time make me feel better. I can definitely feel my symptoms improving as I continue.
I’m a former distance runner myself. I often found that the first 10-15 minutes of ANY long run felt horrible, working away on our anaerobic system until the body ‘clicked’ over to its aerobic state and “by the end I feel good”, as you say. Thanks, Lauren.
Excellent article Carolyn! The biochemical changes are fascinating! All the minute things going on in our bodies ‘just’ from exercise. And the opposite is also true: all the minute things NOT going on in our bodies if we DON’T exercise!
I know from personal experience, it doesn’t take long for the body to improve endurance when pushed just a little.
Thanks for sharing and for spending the time finding these informative facts to enlighten us!!
Thanks so much for your comment, Lynn. It’s ironic that the very thing that would be most helpful for our hearts is sometimes the very thing we tend to avoid! I like Dr. John Mandrola’s philosophy: that we only need to exercise on the days we plan to eat…. 🙂