This is your heart (my Heart Month interview)


by Carolyn Thomas    @HeartSisters

Heart Month (aka February) typically means a flurry of once-a-year media attention to the important subject of women’s heart health, so I like to take advantage of as many interview requests as I can every February.  Strike while the iron’s hot!  Make hay while the sun shines! Drink the glass of wine while it’s sitting right in front of you!  Okay, that last rule I just made up…

One such interview request this year was from Media Planet’s 2016 Cardiovascular Health Campaign launched by Canada’s National Post newspaper and online. Here’s the text of that interview with Taylor Mihail of Media Planet.

Media Planet:  You suffered a myocardial infarction caused by a 99 percent blocked coronary artery. How has that experience shaped your advocacy for heart health?

Carolyn Thomas:   “It’s fair to say I wouldn’t ever have become an advocate for women’s heart health had I not been sent home from the Emergency Department with a misdiagnosis of acid reflux – despite my textbook symptoms of chest pain, nausea, and pain down my left arm. I left the hospital that morning feeling completely embarrassed, because I’d just made a big fuss over nothing!

“Of course, my symptoms returned, over and over – but there was no way I was heading back to that hospital. After all, a man with the letters M.D. after his name had told me quite emphatically: “This is not your heart!”  It was only much later, after finally returning to the Emergency Room because I could no longer bear those increasingly severe acid reflux symptoms that I was correctly diagnosed and treated for what doctors call the “widowmaker heart attack”.

“Afterwards, I felt stunned and angry after I was discharged from the Coronary Intensive Care unit – but also curious about why women heart patients are so often under-diagnosed, as I was, compared to our male counterparts. I knew I had to do something to help other women avoid what I’d gone through. That same year, I applied — and became the first Canadian ever accepted — to attend the WomenHeart Science & Leadership training for women with heart disease at the world-famous Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota.

“Graduating from this community advocacy training offered me an amazing and life-altering opportunity to take what I’d learned at Mayo about women’s heart disease, bring it back home to Victoria, B.C., and start spreading the word.

“By now, I’ve spoken to thousands of women (and a few men!) about women’s heart health, including speaking to health care professionals in their workplaces and at medical conferences. My presentations tend to be very lively, are always full with a waiting list, and have been described as “part cardiology boot camp, and part stand-up comedy!”

MP:   There are a lot of misconceptions surrounding female heart attacks. What should women know?

CT:  “A recent scientific statement on women’s heart attacks from the American Heart Association confirmed many of those misconceptions.  Although chest pain is indeed our most common heart attack symptom, up to 40 percent of women experience no chest symptoms at all during their cardiac events. Even the word “pain” is important: many women would not describe their chest symptom as pain, but often with words like full, heavy, burning, tight or pressure.

“And we can also exhibit what doctors call atypical heart attack symptoms affecting our neck, throat, jaw, back, shoulders, and one or both arms. Nausea, vomiting, cold sweats, crushing fatigue, light-headedness and even what’s known as “a sense of impending doom” are often reported by women in mid-heart attack. As Los Angeles cardiologist Dr. Noel Bairey Merz warns us, Be wary of any symptoms above the waist. Heart trouble can feel like a crick in your neck, a pulled shoulder you might blame on carrying your heavy purse, even a pill stuck in your throat.”

“Another misconception is that if you’re young or thin or fit or have never smoked, you’re somehow immune to heart disease. Not true! What I like to tell my audiences and my blog readers now is this:

“You know your body. You know when something is just not right. Pay attention to that little voice warning you if these symptoms do not feel ‘normal’ to you. And then most importantly, ask yourself what you’d do if it were your daughter, or your mother, or your sister, or your friend experiencing the exact same troubling symptoms. If you would drop everything to seek medical help for them — do the same for yourself!”

MP:  You were originally misdiagnosed. Is this a common experience for women that suffer from heart attacks?

CT:  “Not only are women more likely to be misdiagnosed in mid-heart attack compared to our male counterparts, we are more likely to be under-treated even when appropriately diagnosed. As my heart sister Laura Haywood Cory, a spontaneous coronary artery heart attack survivor, likes to summarize the state of cardiac care for women:

“Sucks to be female. Better luck next life…”

A study published in the New England Journal of Medicine found that, particularly in women in their 50s or younger, we are seven times more likely to be misdiagnosed in mid-heart attack compared to our male counterparts. This is partially due to cardiac diagnostic tests that have been designed, developed and researched on (white, middle-aged) men for most of the past four decades. Cardiac tests that can be very accurate in identifying cardiovascular disease in men may not work as well in women — which is what happened to me when all my cardiac tests first came back “normal”. Women can also present with more atypical heart attack symptoms, but remember that in my own case, I experienced classic Hollywood Heart Attack symptoms — and yet despite those, the E.R. physician still took one look at me and said: “You’re in the right demographic for acid reflux!” before sending me home with instructions to see my GP for a prescription for antacid medication.

MP:  Has your experience with heart attack affected your lifestyle? What changes, if any, have you had to make?

CT:  “My heart attack changed virtually every part of my life. Because of ongoing cardiac issues that emerged during the first few months, I could no longer work. I had to leave my 30+ year public relations career on extended medical leave and apply for a long-term disability pension — a really demoralizing experience for me.

“My day-to-day life had to be carefully restructured to include rest and recuperation after every outing in order to manage the debilitating daily pain and crushing fatigue of coronary microvascular disease.

“I’d always been a person who exercised every day, and I’d been a distance runner for almost 20 years, so I actually had to adapt to exercising less than before after my own cardiac event.

“At Mayo Clinic, we learned that eating what’s known as the Mediterranean diet is considered cardioprotective: lots of veggies and fruit, very little red meat or processed foods, whole grains, fatty fish like salmon — and fun stuff like red wine and dark chocolate!

“Finally, I don’t think I really understood how much chronic daily stress I’d been living with for years. For example, I’d started normalizing the fact that for the year leading up to my heart attack, I’d gone into work almost every weekend, trying to keep on top of my workload. We know now that this kind of low-grade stress is very damaging to the heart. I’ve really had to learn how to pace myself, that the word NO is a complete sentence, and that bragging about how crazy-busy I am is not a sign of good health, but of a life that’s out of control.

MP:  How has your blog, Heart Sisters, helped to spread awareness for cardiovascular health?

CT:   “I started my website Heart Sisters in 2009 as just a static little three-page site with information on how to book my fun Pinot & Prevention” presentations about women’s heart health, which I started doing after I returned home from my WomenHeart Science & Leadership training. I slowly started writing general articles about what I’d learned at Mayo and other credible sources, and before I knew it, the site had exploded to over 600 articles, attracting six million views so far in 190 countries! And many of my blog posts have been republished internationally, including in the British Medical Journal. All of this is truly amazing to me!

“I like to call my blog writing ‘cardiac rehab for my brain. My public relations friends tease me that this is what happens when a PR person has a heart attack: we just keep on doing the only thing we know how to do, which is writing and speaking! I’m also thrilled by the hundreds of physicians who now follow my blog and my social media posts on Twitter or Facebook; I suspect these online relationships have happened because I’m a stickler for evidence-based medicine. While I like to write about the patient perspective, I also refer to scientific studies to support what I write.

“I try very hard to make sure that what I do provide to readers is a unique resource that’s both useful and credible. Last year, the Vancouver Coastal Research Foundation described me as a “knowledge translator after I spoke to a full house at one of their community education events about women’s heart health. I love that job description! I’ve taught myself how to read medical journals, and then how to reduce the key findings of published research into plain English for my readers.

“And speaking of plain English, I have to tell you that the blog post I’m most proud of is my patient-friendly, jargon-free glossary of hundreds of confusing cardiology terms. I’m also proud that Heart Sisters has earned “Health On The Net” certification (it’s a European-based watchdog organization that recommends my site as a source for trustworthy health care information online). There’s an awful lot of trash online, and it can be tough for patients to plough through the trash to find the truth!”

MP:   With more awareness and education, could the effects of heart attacks in women be reduced?

CT:  “I sure hope so! It’s why I keep doing what I’m doing! Most cardiologists believe that 80% of heart disease is actually preventable. Yet an interesting study of women over 40 from The Federation of Medical Women of Canada found that only about 10 percent of women are aware of all of their cardiac risk factors compared to 64 percent of women surveyed who knew exactly what they weighed in high school!

“Generally, Canadian women seem to have our overall priorities mixed up. If we wait until a heart attack happens, doctors may be able to stent or bypass or zap us back to life, but that procedure focuses only on what we call the specific “culprit” blockage that caused the heart attack in the first place. It won’t cure what caused that coronary artery damage, likely many years previously.

“But if we begin to make smart lifestyle changes, we’ll see major effects of those improvements throughout our whole bodies — which means we’ll feel better overall while very likely preventing that heart attack! It’s why cardiologist Dr. John Mandrola tells his patients:  “You only have to exercise on the days you plan to eat!” I love that advice!

MP:   What advice would you give to women across Canada to stay heart healthy?

CT:  “The standard advice includes what everybody already knows. The basic lifestyle choices we all know we should embrace to stay heart healthy include: eat heart-smart foods, maintain a healthy weight, exercise regularly, quit smoking, get a good night’s sleep, cultivate meaningful social connections, manage your blood pressure/cholesterol/chronic stress.

“But there’s something else that underlies every one of these choices, and that’s about women making themselves a priority in their own lives. Until that happens, we’ll always find something more important that needs doing (rather than taking time to exercise because that’s what our body really needs). When Mayo Clinic did a study that asked women to rank what’s most important in their lives, the results were telling:

  1. Family/children
  2. Work
  3. Home
  4. Pets (!)
  5. Husbands (right under the dog!)
  6. Myself

“As long as we continue to put ourselves last on our own priority lists, we’re just not going to make heart health important enough to pursue.

“You can take time now, or you’ll have to make time later!”

© 2016 MediaPlanet

Q:  What advice would you offer to women about their heart health?

See also:


9 thoughts on “This is your heart (my Heart Month interview)

  1. I have suffered 2 Takasubo’s (broken heart Syndrome) in the last 4 yrs and I would like to know what you have for info on this. I have a great cardiologist but not much is known of this different heart attack. I also would like to make the girls know of this kind of Heart Attack.


  2. Love reading your articles, so easy and to the point.

    I was sent home with a misdiagnosis (twisted esophagus), got home and called straight back to CCU – I had a blockage of 90%. This was treated with drug coated balloon (no stent), no heart damage. This was 6 months ago.

    My one frustration is it seems it’s all about how many tablets my consultant can prescribe and not how I have tried to change my diet/stress and lifestyle (action not attention). I’ve lost 21 pounds. I’m running the marathon and I feel great – I ask lots of questions and I’m happy to challenge – this does not seem to go down very well – I’ve dropped the statins and I will continue to live a stress free (three years very badly stressed) life going forward and keep improving my lifestyle.

    Thank you again and I look forward to reading more … 👍

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks B – it turns out that the squeezing chest pain of esophageal spasm can indeed sometimes be mistaken for heart attack! Glad you went right back to hospital in time. Congrats on making those significant lifestyle improvements – and best of luck to you in your marathon!


  3. Dear Carolyn,
    I want to thank you with all my heart, including my clogged arteries, for your blog.

    I discovered it in the hospital after my heart attack, while I was laying in my bed in the CCU waiting for tests and treatments, taking Heparin, and having my blood enzymes measured periodically (I had a stent the next day). I had my iPad with me and found your blog almost immediately! It was so reassuring to read all the info you have packed into it and it has been my guide in the 2 1/2 years since my heart attack.

    I tell many women about it and am proud you are from Canada, as I am too!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hello Chris and thanks very much – I’m always so glad to hear from other Canucks (the vast majority of my readers are from the U.S, then the U.K. and then Canada way down the list). Somehow, I just love picturing you lying in CCU with your little iPad and finding my site… When I think back to my own time spent in the CCU post-MI, overwhelmed and scared, I really wish that I’d had been able to find the kind of info I’ve been able to pack into this blog since then! 😉


  4. Carolyn, THANK YOU!

    Thank you for creating and providing a place for people to turn to to better understand women’s heart disease. Thank you for raising awareness of a pervasive health problem that for too long has been marginalized, poorly diagnosed, and even out and out ignored. (Women, it turns out, are not just small men!) Your impact is far greater than even your impressive website metrics and many awards and achievements suggest. You have saved lives and given hope to countless people facing the darkest point of their lives.

    Women are often the principal caregivers and we tend to put other people’s needs before ourselves, as the Mayo Clinic study suggests. Not only does that put our own health at risk, but it also short-circuits our caregiving aspirations.

    We can’t take care of anyone else if we aren’t healthy and strong. Self-care and good health are the study foundation needed to effectively care for others.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Carolyn,
    Thank you for all that you do to raise awareness of cardiac disease in women. I’m learning a lot from reading your articles. I can relate to much of what you said — making everyone else’s needs a higher priority than mine, and accepting chronic stress as normal, even a sign of being a hard worker and a team player. For me, there was also denial (“I am too young and healthy to have a heart attack!”) — and it didn’t help that the EKG looked normal!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for your kind words, Susan. That denial you mention, as researchers are now telling us, is surprisingly common! One of my readers told me of ignoring her very significant heart attack symptoms because they hit on the morning of Christmas Eve – and she had her whole big family arriving next day for Christmas dinner! Priorities!!!


Your opinion matters. What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s