“Can’t go to my support group meeting because my husband’s expecting dinner”

by Carolyn Thomas    @HeartSisters

screen-shot-2016-11-09-at-1-45-37-pmI opened an email recently from one of my Mayo heart sisters. She had dropped me a note because she was concerned about a woman (a recent heart attack survivor) who had told her she really wanted to attend their community’s next support group meeting for women living with heart disease (this one was a monthly meeting held from 3-4:30 p.m.). But this woman claimed that she couldn’t go to the meeting – because she “had to be home to cook dinner for her husband.” Although her hubby was retired and at home all day long, the heart attack survivor explained that “he expects to have dinner ready at the regular time that I have had it for him all the years he was working.”

My initial reaction (after checking the calendar just to make sure it’s not still 1950): I need to go have a wee lie-down to recuperate from reading this story.

My friend had asked this woman: “So you can’t tell him that you want this 90 minutes a month, this short time to be with women like yourself, to help you learn more about living with heart disease?”


My friend: “Did you make dinner for him when you had your heart attack, or during your recovery?”

“No. He asked my daughter, and she did.”

Of course, we don’t know the exact personal circumstances of this woman who couldn’t attend a support group following her own heart attack because she had to stay home and serve dinner.

Perhaps hers was an abusive relationship and she was afraid of him.

Perhaps she was old school and it hadn’t even occurred to her to tell him what she wanted to do.

Perhaps he was bedridden and couldn’t lift a fork to his mouth on his own.

Perhaps she had signed a personal servitude contract with him and could be legally liable if she missed a dinner.

I suspect that this scenario, however, is less about a demanding husband and more about a wife who has trained that husband on how to treat her, on what she’s willing to put up with, and on the place in life she believes she deserves. I’m guessing this is also about the profound belief that her own needs are simply not as important as those of her spouse and others.

This reluctance of so many women to let their own needs interfere with other people’s is not unique to this woman.

You would think that there are few things more important in life than having/surviving a heart attack. But even in mid-heart attack, we already know that women are far more likely than men to come up with reasons to delay seeking emergency help for themselves in a way they’d never delay if the person having identical symptoms were their daughter, mother, spouse, sister or friend. In a Mayo Clinic survey(1) on women’s top priorities in life, the results showed that women tend to rank what’s most important in this order:

  1. children
  2. home
  3. work
  4. pets
  5. spouse (yes, right below the dog!)
  6. self

This survey’s truly pathetic last place ranking confirming women’s unwillingness to put ourselves first on our own priority lists may help to explain why this particular woman’s need to go to a support group meeting wasn’t as important to her as serving her husband’s dinner was. What the hell – this survey suggests that, for some women, they’d put the dog’s dinner needs ahead of their own!

Female heart patients may not only put serving dinner ahead of their own needs, but even lifesaving cardiac rehabilitation programs. Dr. Chris Blanchard is a health psychologist at Dalhousie University in Halifax whose research has shown that women are up to 30% more likely to quit these programs than men – despite knowing that completing a supervised cardiac rehab program can reduce mortality in heart patients by 25-40%. Even when women don’t drop out of rehab outright, they’re more likely to attend only sporadically. Out of a typical 20-session cardiac rehab program, Dr. Blanchard found that men will generally attend 80% of sessions, compared to women who will attend only 50-60% of the time. See also: Why aren’t women heart attack survivors showing up for cardiac rehab?

So why do women have such poor attendance records, or end up being rehab dropouts at these lifesaving programs?  According to Dr. Blanchard, it’s because women put themselves low on their priority lists.

“Women are caretakers for other people, and they undersell themselves. That’s the biggest gender discrepancy I’ve seen.”

Perhaps the women  who do put themselves dead last (only after everybody else’s needs are already met first) might also suffer from what’s been described as Type E personalities:  Everything To Everybody’. Is it because women are, from birth, socialized to be nurturers and caretakers, sometimes even at the expense of our own health?

In fact, when we do take time for ourselves, we can sometimes feel like we’re being selfish, which, as we all know, is the worst possible way to be. And we can even resent others who DO carve out specific time to devote exclusively to themselves and their own health.

Here’s another dangerous example of our out-of-whack priorities: a number of cardiac researchers have spent years investigating a unique phenomenon that they call women’s treatment-seeking delaybehaviour in mid-heart attack. This delay is extremely dangerous because “time is muscle” when it comes to making the decision to get early cardiac symptoms assessed as soon as possible to prevent permanent heart muscle damage or death due to a serious cardiac event. See also: Knowing & Going’ – act fast when heart attack symptoms hit

Being in an unhappy marriage in which your own needs are not considered worthy can also cause significant physical harm.

A University of Rochester study predicted that 83% of happily married women will still be alive 15 years after cardiac bypass surgery, versus only 28% of female bypass surgery patients living in unhappy marriages.

Research also suggests that being happily married can have a big effect on helping us recover from serious health crises like a heart attack. (For men, by the way, marriage doesn’t even have to be particularly happy to increase positive health outcomes. Just the mere state of being married, happily or miserably, apparently leads to better outcomes in males). But we know that just being married is not in itself a guarantee that women will be supported by their spouses during recuperation from chronic illness. A 2009 study on “partner abandonment” among married couples, for example, conducted at the University of Washington in Seattle found that men are six times more likely to leave a relationship because of their partner’s serious illness than wives are. Among those study participants, the divorce rate was 21 percent for seriously ill women, but just 3 per cent for seriously ill men. A control group divorced at a rate of 12 per cent, suggesting that if disease of a spouse makes husbands more likely to split, it makes wives more likely to stay.

The prognosis, for women heart patients particularly, seems directly linked to the quality of that spousal relationship. But what about women who are afraid to leave an unhappy relationship, reluctant to be on their own while struggling with a heart condition? As I asked here in 2013:

“Wouldn’t the prospect of being on her own after a divorce be far worse for a woman living with a serious illness than staying in an unhappy marriage?

Not according to a recent U.K. study of 10,000 people over a 20-year period, published in the journal, Economica. It suggests that, in general, women who leave an unhappy marriage are much more content than men after divorce – even more so than their baseline level of happiness throughout their lives. Study author Dr. Yannis Georgellis explained:

“In the study, we took into account the fact that divorce can sometimes have a negative financial impact on women, but despite that it still makes them much happier than men.”

Dearest readers, if you’re ever in a relationship in which you have somehow convinced yourself that you don’t have the right to make your own heart health a clear priority in your life, remember these fundamental human rights, as outlined by Preston Ni in his Psychology Today column:

  • You have the right to be treated with respect.
  • You have the right to express your feelings, opinions and wants.
  • You have the right to set your own priorities.
  • You have the right to say “no” without feeling guilty. 
  • You have the right to have opinions different than others.
  • You have the right to take care of and protect yourself from being threatened physically, mentally or emotionally.
  • You have the right to create your own happy and healthy life.

And if you need somebody to remind yourself that you deserve these rights, please seek professional help and a good lawyer.

  1. “Hierarchy of Female Concerns”, Mayo Clinic survey, 2000; results presented by Mayo cardiologist Dr. Sharonne Hayes at the 2008 WomenHeart Science & Leadership Symposium For Women With Heart Disease, Mayo Clinic, Rochester.
  2. Nancy Henry, Tim Smith. University of Utah. Presented to the 2009 American Psychosomatic Society’s annual meeting, Chicago.

Q:  Why are some women reluctant to express their own needs? 

See also:

Marriage triples our bypass surgery survival rates – but only if it’s happy

When being married makes being sick worse

Poor Marriage = Poor Heart Health For Women

Women heart attack survivors know their place

Is family stress hurting your heart?

Can denial ever be a good thing for heart patients?

Knowing & Going: act fast when heart attack symptoms hit

Downplaying symptoms: just pretend it’s NOT a heart attack

How we adapt after a heart attack may depend on what we believe this diagnosis means

Which one’s right? Eight ways that patients and families can view heart disease

Six personality coping patterns that influence how you handle heart disease

The new country called heart disease


5 thoughts on ““Can’t go to my support group meeting because my husband’s expecting dinner”

  1. Pingback: ju6y
  2. I’ve told parts of my story before but this particular post really hits home to me in a way that I’ve never publicly stated before. I was a people pleaser and trying desperately to hold a failing marriage together when my heart attack happened.

    Because of financial issues and our strained relationship, I did not wake my husband or call 911 for help that night. We couldn’t afford the doctor’s visit or an ED visit, or so I thought. Since I lived through the night, I continued my denial and didn’t go to the hospital for 2 more weeks. By then, I was in almost complete respiratory distress as my heart and lungs were filling up with fluid.

    Needless to say, I lost a considerable amount of heart muscle (65%) and when I finally presented in the ED, they attempted to stent my LAD unsuccessfully and because of the muscle damage, a By-Pass operation was no long an option. One of my own coping mechanisms is the fact that the doctors can’t emphatically say that the damage wasn’t done at the moment of the heart attack and not the result of my delaying treatment.

    I’m lucky, despite an Ejection Fraction that ranges from 14-19%, I am very well managed with medications. I function like anyone else my age (58), I control my diet and can walk 2 1/2 miles in 30 minutes. No one would ever suspect that I live with a serious heart condition. I’m always met with great disbelief when I do tell people about my experiences.

    Through it all, my now ex-husband was the model of perfectly supporting spouse, but that quickly ended and he became quite the opposite when no one was watching. His “act” was passive aggressive, to say the least. It took me two more years, but I filed for divorce and even when I was left with absolutely nothing; no money, no home (it was in foreclosure since he stopped paying the mortgage) and very few personal belongings, I was happier than I had ever been.

    Now, slightly over three years later, I am a new woman. Yes, I still have a serious heart condition but I’ve changed careers (finally decided that helping others was critical to my happiness), returned to school after three decades (completing my Masters degree in Social Work this spring) and blissfully going after my dreams. Living alone but never as lonely as I had been before in my marriage.

    There comes a time to put ourselves first, my heart attack was my wake up call. Life is too short and that’s not a cliche. I hope that others find their happiness in whatever way they desire too.

    (sorry for the long post, this was really cathartic for me to write!)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Wow. What a story, Eve. I was especially moved when you wrote: “I did not wake my husband or call 911 for help.” You have no idea how many of my readers have told me that they didn’t wake their husbands when their heart attack symptoms hit in the middle of the night because they “didn’t want to disturb him”. What they’re actually saying is that they’d rather be dead than wake him up. This is true both for women like you living in a troubled marriage, and for women who are happy with their husbands! But when a woman is afraid/reluctant FOR ANY REASON to wake up her husband when she is ill and afraid, you know there is something seriously wrong (with at least one of them). Congratulations to you – first of all for surviving what many do not, and for moving on to a better life!


  3. It’s also possible the woman in question is trying to regain a sense of normalcy in her life. Her action may be self-protective – not in a positive way, from our perspective, but necessary for her at this point in time. As she comes to terms with her experience of life-threatening disease, she may find a support group helpful. Many people react that way to life-changing events. Denial is real, but often passes if friends and relatives give appropriate support. Let’s not judge this person, but provide that support.

    PS – there are no support groups in my area, and no, I don’t have the energy to start one!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Good points, Holly. This particular woman did say she really wanted to attend, but some women say they want to ____ (insert appropriate goal) even when they really don’t, deep down inside – possibly for the reasons you mention, and possibly because they have learned to make other people and things more important on their priority lists. That’s also where the WomenHeart online support community on Inspire can fill the gap. Free to join, open 24/7, over 25,000 women living with heart disease.


Your opinion matters. What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s